Little Paradise on Anastasia Island

404 Old Quarry Road
St Augustine, FL 32080
MLS Number: 194712
Property Status: Sold
Property Type: Residential
Price: $2,100,000
Year Built: 1917
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 4
Lot Size: 1.84 ac.
Living Area: 3,699 sq. ft.
Property Features: Central air, Central heat, Covered porch, Detached cottage, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric heat, Family room, Fireplace, Garage, Garden, Gas cook stove, In-law suite, Microwave, On-site parking, Partial fence, Patio, Pool, Porch, Range, Refrigerator, Shed, Storage, Vaulted Ceiling, Washer, Workshop

Contact Irene
Cell: 904.669.0691


In days gone by you would have enjoyed afternoon tea or dinner ($3.00 and $1.50 respectively) at the Buccaneer Lodge and sat on this very porch. Fast forward to 2020 and the magic of this beloved estate is even more enticing. A natural sanctuary lies within this walled compound where live oaks and songbirds happily share the peaceful beauty with the people who will call Little Paradise their new home.

Electric gates swing open revealing a circular brick drive and paths that lead to the house, caretaker cottage/studio and standalone garage. Grounds stretch out in all directions – explore and you’ll find a deliciously private pool with spa and sun patio, a folly, enviable tree-house for the younger crowd and a lovely window-lined building with fireplace that has been studio, gym and party room. Wraparound porch embraces the main residence and it’s true that time really does slow down here. Diffused light streams into the living room where a fireplace waits patiently for cool evenings. Hidden door in the bookshelves opens to office/5th bedroom with private bath. Oyster shells adorn the dining room fireplace and kitchen fuses form with function beautifully. Take in the hand-built cabinetry, island, butler’s pantry and the stove and watch your culinary muse shine. Adjacent family room connects you to family and guests. Mud room is a storage lover’s dream and laundry room provides even more.

Upstairs two master en-suites offer spacious sleeping quarters plus a laundry room. West bedroom has reading alcove, custom closet and the best view of a magnificent oak from the tub. East bedroom is out of a storybook with lofty ceiling, wall of mirrored doors opening to wonderful closets and a bathroom clad in marble. Guest wing offers another bedroom on 2nd floor with hall bath and outfitted closet. Spiral stair leads to the loft bedroom – be ready for negotiations about who gets this space! Words and photos cannot convey the enchantment of this oasis so this is just a wee taste.

Irene Arriola Real Estate, Inc.
81 King Street, Suite B Saint Augustine, FL 32084
Email: [email protected] | Office phone: 904.829.2002
Cell phone: 904.669.0691 | Fax: 904.829.2029